Is Afghanistan a Haunted Country?
By Yawer Qazalbash
Some people may contemplate that the title of this presentation is irrational, or even superstitious, but if one studies and delve upon sequential facts of history of Afghanistan the natural inference would manifest itself to justify the expression. Strangely enough, perhaps this is the only country in the world which was invaded by outsiders most of the times, but with same results.
The point may be clarified if we divide the foreign conquerors of Afghanistan, past and present, in two categories: those who subjugated that country and tried to rule it from outside; and, those outsiders who subjugated Afghanistan and then settled there permanently. During the course of replicating history, it can be observed that outsiders who tried to remote control that country not only lost control, but sooner or later their great empires went to shreds in majority of cases. On the other hand the second category ruled there for centuries, irrespective of differences of races etc.
If we look deep into history of Afghanistan, various versions are available trying to trace the origin of Afghan people. Chronicles and legends mention that Afghan people descended from an Israeli king Saul, through his son Jeremiah and his son Afghana (lost tribe). Farishta says that the descent came from Copts (Pharaoh). According to one story they descended from Qais, a pious man who embraced Islam in its 9th year. Yet another story refers the name of Bilo.
However, as far as recorded history is concerned, it was first invaded around 665 AD by Zaid, the governor of Khurasan, who was appointed by Damascus under Omayyad dynasty. King of Kabul accepted allegiance but very soon denied to pay. Muslims again invaded Afghanistan in 684 AD but were defeated. Other attack came around 690 AD by Abdul Rahman, another Omayyad governor, and history is witness that the Omayyad dynasty, which was controlling the world of those times, started to fall and power eventually went to Abbasids at Baghdad. Then outsiders Alaptgeen-Subuktageen established themselves at Ghazni (922-1186AD) and ruled Afghanistan successfully till the rise of Ghaurees (1165-1214AD), who were by descent Surees and also outsiders but permanently settled there, and this was their story of success.
Around 1221 AD Mongols under Changez Khan plundered and subjugated Afghanistan, but afterwards the empire was divided and his descendent Ila Khan got Iran and Afghanistan as his share, who established his capital in Iran, Afghanistan remained as a province . The family of great Mongols not only lost Afghanistan, but they were eliminated from the pages of history.
The next in line was family of Timur, a Mirza Mughal, who conquered Afghanistan in 1398 AD and became native of that country. The family ruled there continuously till Babur left Afghanistan in the year 1526 AD and later he, along with his descendents permanently settled in India.
It would be in order to mention here that Akbar the great, grandson of Babar, powerfully ruling at Delhi, sent a large army with a view to subjugate the land of his forefathers under the guidance of Birbal, who was killed there and Mughal army was defeated.
The ‘Great Britain’, while ruling India, invaded and fought two major Afghan wars, from 1838 to 1842 and 1878 to 1880. Soon after Kabul was captured in 1838 a revolt broke out and Alex Burnes and Macnaghton were murdered, and the 4500 British soldiers remained besieged in the garrison at Kabul, hence after efforts a convention was signed and soldiers were allowed to leave, but during their retreat entire troop were overwhelmed at Jagdalak pass and only Dr. Brydon reached Jalalabad alive but wounded.
British again entered Afghan borders in 1879, but not deep enough to hamper retreat options. A treaty was signed with Yaqub Khan and an envoy was deputed in May 1879, but in September the envoy and his staff was massacred. In retaliation British captured Kabul but were repulsed later.
Fate of Russian invasion and its disintegration is well known, as it is an event of very recent past.
In the contemporary world, the US invasion, its impact on the US itself and its stipulated withdrawal from Afghanistan in 2014 has become a material for debate and analysis world over.
Innumerous ideas and opinions are coming to fore, including the recent opinion of Dalrymple. As is evident from above mentioned facts of history, every one of the conqueror of Afghanistan was a world power of its time and in each case the cause of their exit was the ‘unavoidable circumstances’, and not the Afghan’s “inbred hatred of strangers in race and religion”, nor the inherent fighting tendencies of Afghan people, because it was not the actual military defeat the invaders faced. The common factor of naturally occurring ‘unavoidable circumstances’ could be taken as an answer to the question posed in the title of this presentation.
In this scenario many groups in the US, or in India as well, are lobbying to convince government and people of India to fill the void created after US withdrawal in 2014, on various hypothetical grounds. Feelers are being floated in this regard. Such exercise is being done to get India indulged in Afghanistan adventure, so that others may be saved from aftermath of Afghan brunt in future. India should watch its own interest.
.END
ps: comments are invited.